5. Paul WilliamsBugsy Malone

I wonder if a little kid is watching that movie, is it scary? Because when the kids get shot with the pie or whatever, they disappear, they don’t come back, you’re dead. I love the sound of all the songs, and the songwriting is amazing – it’s just one of those perfect combinations of songwriting and production, and I think he sings all the songs. That’s what gives the film its unique tone, because it could be this soupy Disney-style exploitation of the innocence of a child’s voice, but it’s this grown man, and you fully buy into the reality of the setting. Sure it’s a send up of the Prohibition-era gangster genre but you can watch the scene of the guy singing ‘Tomorrow’ and start weeping – it’s just so real. And you’ve got the little girl dancing around doing her ballet, it gives you shivers. And it’s a very dark movie, it kind of looks like The Godfather, very darkly lit. Jodie Foster is amazing – she’s like one of the best child actors of all time. I think that a great musical has its moments of hilarity and then also moments of deep sadness, pathos. I think we probably veered too far on the dark side with our musical.